Important NMFC changes coming July 19, 2025. The NMFTA will consolidate ~2,000 commodity listings in the first phase of the 2025-1 docket. Learn more or contact your sales rep.

    HomeComparisonsLogistics KPI vs Make-to-Stock (MTS)Direct Store Delivery (DSD) vs General Order (GO)Logistics as a Service vs Demand Forecasting​​​

    Logistics KPI vs Make-to-Stock (MTS): Detailed Analysis & Evaluation

    Make-to-Stock (MTS) vs Logistics KPI: A Comprehensive Comparison

    Introduction

    Make-to-Stock (MTS) and Logistics Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are two foundational concepts in supply chain management, addressing distinct yet interconnected aspects of production and operational efficiency. Comparing these frameworks provides insights into strategic decision-making, optimizing inventory levels, and enhancing logistics performance. This comparison explores their definitions, applications, advantages, and limitations to guide businesses in selecting the right approach for their needs.

    What is Make-to-Stock (MTS)?

    Definition

    Make-to-Stock (MTS) is a production strategy where goods are manufactured in anticipation of future demand, based on historical sales data, market trends, and forecasts. Products are produced to stock inventory before receiving customer orders.

    Key Characteristics:

    1. Demand Forecasting: Relies on predictive analytics to anticipate customer needs.
    2. Standardized Processes: Focuses on mass production of standardized products (e.g., consumer goods).
    3. Inventory Management: Maintains buffer stocks to meet fluctuating demand and minimize stockouts.
    4. Lead Time Efficiency: Reduces lead times for customers by having inventory ready for immediate shipment.

    History & Importance:

    • Originated in the early 20th century with Ford’s assembly line model.
    • Critical for industries with predictable demand (e.g., fast-moving consumer goods) to balance supply and demand efficiently.

    What is Logistics KPI?

    Definition

    Logistics Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are measurable metrics used to evaluate the efficiency, effectiveness, and performance of logistics operations across sourcing, production, transportation, and distribution.

    Key Characteristics:

    1. Operational Metrics: Examples include order fulfillment rate, shipping time, inventory turnover ratio, and cost per mile.
    2. Data-Driven Insights: Leverages real-time data to identify bottlenecks and optimize processes.
    3. Customer-Centric Focus: Aligns with goals like on-time delivery, reduced costs, and enhanced customer satisfaction.

    History & Importance:

    • Evolved from basic supply chain metrics in the 1980s to advanced analytics tools (e.g., IoT sensors, AI algorithms).
    • Vital for modern businesses to remain competitive, especially in industries with complex global supply chains (e.g., e-commerce, automotive).

    Key Differences

    | Aspect | Make-to-Stock (MTS) | Logistics KPI |
    |------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------|
    | Objective | Optimize production based on forecasted demand | Measure and improve logistics efficiency |
    | Scope | Focused on manufacturing inventory management | Encompasses entire supply chain (procurement to delivery) |
    | Data Sources | Historical sales data, market trends | Real-time operational data (e.g., shipping times, orders) |
    | Success Metrics | Minimized stockouts/overstock; high inventory turnover | High on-time delivery rates; low transportation costs |
    | Flexibility | Rigid if forecasts are inaccurate | Adaptable through continuous monitoring and adjustments |

    Use Cases

    When to Use MTS:

    • Predictable Demand: Ideal for industries with stable, recurring customer orders (e.g., toiletries, electronics).
    • Seasonal Peaks: Stockpile items in advance of holidays or seasonal spikes (e.g., winter clothing).
    • Example: A company like Coca-Cola uses MTS to ensure consistent supply of sodas year-round.

    When to Use Logistics KPIs:

    • Complex Supply Chains: Essential for industries with global distribution networks (e.g., Amazon, automotive manufacturers).
    • Cost Optimization: Track metrics like cost per mile or warehouse efficiency to reduce expenses.
    • Customer Satisfaction: Measure average order cycle time to ensure fast deliveries.

    Advantages and Disadvantages

    MTS:

    Advantages

    1. Reduces lead times for customers.
    2. Efficient for high-volume, standardized products.

    Disadvantages

    1. High inventory holding costs if forecasts are inaccurate.
    2. Risk of obsolescence or overstocking in volatile markets.

    Logistics KPIs:

    Advantages

    1. Enhances visibility into supply chain inefficiencies.
    2. Improves customer satisfaction through faster, cheaper deliveries.

    Disadvantages

    1. Requires significant investment in data collection tools and analytics.
    2. May overwhelm teams with excessive metrics if not prioritized.

    Popular Examples

    MTS:

    • Consumer Goods: Unilever manufactures detergent stockpiles based on historical sales.
    • Retail: Walmart pre-produces holiday toys to meet seasonal demand.

    Logistics KPIs:

    • E-commerce: Amazon tracks order-to-cash cycle time to streamline payments and deliveries.
    • Automotive: Tesla measures shipment accuracy rates to ensure defect-free vehicle delivery.

    Conclusion

    MTS and logistics KPIs serve complementary roles in modern supply chains. MTS excels at managing inventory for predictable demand, while logistics KPIs provide actionable insights into operational performance. Businesses should adopt a hybrid approach: use MTS for stable product lines and leverage logistics KPIs to optimize distribution networks and customer satisfaction.

    Need further assistance? Let me know!

    ← Direct Store Delivery (DSD) vs General Order (GO)Logistics as a Service vs Demand Forecasting →